gies available and the current economic and commercial interests
and that the limits allowed today may be different in
the future and from what they were in the past, thus they are
not established in relation to the harm they cause to health,
but have more to do with the technological packages currently
available and the companies involved.
According to FAO (2000) sensory analysis studies have
been performed to determine differences in the organoleptic
properties of fruits and vegetables such as apples, tomatoes
and carrots, in which the persons interviewed have recognized
better flavor and color in organic as compared to conventional
produce. In addition, it has been recognized that
there are fewer losses due to fungi attacks during the storage
of organic produce.
It is recognized that many developing countries have deficient
food safety systems due to weak public infrastructure
and incomplete or obsolete legislation that is not in line with
international standards; there are even shortcomings in the
developed world, when primary production is not covered.
In addition, the responsibilities related to food safety and
food control tend to be dispersed among several institutions
and the laboratories lack the equipment and basic supplies
they need, all of which is aggravated by climatic conditions.
The shortcomings of the food safety systems may result in
an increase in food problems and food diseases. Diarrheal
diseases, for example, provoked mainly by the consumption
of unhealthy food and water, take the lives of 1.8 million
children each year (FAO, 2007).
Almost all chemical pesticides authorized in conventional
food production are prohibited in organic production;
therefore contamination may be very low in organic
products. More than 500 additives are authorized in conventional
foods, but only 30 additives are authorized in
organic foods. It has been concluded that a predominantly
organic diet reduces the amount of toxic chemicals ingested,
avoids transgenics, reduces the quantity of food additives
and coloring; increases the consumption of vitamins, minerals,
essential fatty acids and beneficial antioxidants; and appears
to have the potential to lower the incidence of cancer,
coronary heart disease, allergies and hyperactivity in children
(Cleeton, 2004).
The Regional Conference of Consumers of Healthy
Food, held in Bogotá, Colombia, in August 2004, organized
by Consumers International, Office for Latin America
and the Caribbean, recognized that the use of pesticides as
well as the presence of pesticide residues in foods present in
the market are a major concern for the consumers’ movement,
since quality and safety include the primary stage of
production and the processing of such products. Accordingly,
emphasis was placed on the need for a comprehensive
approach to ensuring safety, from production to final
consumption, through sustainable agricultural production.
It was emphasized that the cooperation and joint action of
Consumers International with Latin American networks
such as RAP-AL (Red de Acción en Plaguicidas y sus Alternativas
en América Latina, Pesticide Action Network
in Latin America) and MAELA (Latin American Agroecology
Movement) play an essential role here. It is also
crucial that strategic partnerships be strengthened with
the women’s movement to work on issues of food security
and food sovereignty, health promotion, promoting |
|
breastfeeding and safe foods (Consumers International,
2004).
Although organic or agroecological foods are of significantly
better quality than conventional ones, it cannot be
said that they are totally safe. For example, one may find
detectable levels of persistent organic pollutants (POPs) in
organic or agroecological foods, such as DDT and other organochlorine
insecticides that are no longer used because
they accumulated in the soil for years.8 Agroecological produce
may also contain residues of other chemical pesticides
that reach it by drift, with rain, or with contaminated waters,
but also less frequently and in lower concentrations than in
conventional produce (FAO, 2000; Bordeleau, 2002).
Animal manure and other organic waste such as biosolids
or sludge from wastewater treatment plants, which
may be used as fertilizer in ecological agriculture, may pose
risks of contamination by pathogenic microorganisms that
survive inadequate composting conditions (FAO, 2000).
It might be thought that organic foods pose risks of contamination
with aflatoxins, a by-product of the contamination
of foods with certain fungi in conditions favorable
for them, given that they occur without the use of chemical
fungicides. Nonetheless, it has been shown that such is not
the case. Aflatoxins, which may induce cancer of the liver
at very low dosages if ingested over a prolonged period of
time, may be avoided by good practices in farming, postharvest
handling and storage. Studies have been reported
that found that the level of aflatoxin in organic milk was
lower than in conventional milk (FAO, 2000).
With regard to post-harvest handling, the vitamin C
content and the dry matter are, on average, greater in organic
crops and the percentage of water less, therefore they
keep better than products handled with chemicals, since they
are more resistant to diseases and pests (Barg and Queirós,
2007).
1.7.4 Impacts of the production systems
1.7.4.1 Environmental impacts
Agriculture general impacts. There is widespread agreement
that habitat destruction and fragmentation is the major
driver of biodiversity loss worldwide. While habitat destruction
and fragmentation have many causes, foremost among
them in terms of the area affected is agriculture (Goudie,
1990; Heywood and Watson, 1995; McNeely and Scherr,
2003; MA, 2005b). Siltation of water bodies caused by the
removal of natural vegetative cover can have similarly negative
effects on aquatic and marine organisms. Agriculture
directly impacts aquatic biodiversity when excessive water
is removed for irrigation. Production practices, such as
burning cleared vegetation, can cause additional loss of biodiversity.
Livestock contributes enormous amounts of methane
to the world’s atmosphere, which in turn contributes to
climate change and impacts biodiversity (Clay, 2004). Some
species introduced for agricultural purposes have become
____________________
8 These persistent contaminants are called organic because
they contain carbon in their molecule since they are manufactured
from fossil fuels, but their use is prohibited in organic
agriculture. |