treadmill” has caused a continuous increase in the use of pesticides
in the region. The phenomenon is well-established in
the scientific literature and is responsible for crop losses due
to pests and diseases, which have increased notably despite
the ever greater use of pesticides (Pimentel et al., 1978).
Particularly worrisome at present is the increase in weeds
resistant to herbicides, mainly glyphosate, due to the establishment
of herbicide-resistant or -tolerant varieties, such as
Roundup-Ready soybean from Monsanto (Box 1-7). From
2000 to 2005, the number of biotypes of herbicide-resistant
weeds climbed from 235 to 296 and to 178 species. All these
factors combine with the vast expanses of single-crop agriculture
characteristic of the conventional/productivist production
system to create conditions that are unsustainable
in the long run (Matson et al., 1997).
1.7.2.3 Agroecological system
The agroecological systems have emerged in response to the
lack of sustainability and the environmental and health impacts
of the conventional/productivist system. One of the pillars
of the agroecological systems is the elimination or reduction
in the use of pesticides and synthetic fertilizers; the other
pillar is biodiversity. A recent study of 286 agroecological
projects with small-scale producers in 57 countries of Africa,
Asia and Latin America and the Caribbean found that while
the average yield increased 79%, there were also increases in
the efficiency of water use and the potential for carbon sequestration.
Also contributing to the increase in the sustainability
of the systems, the study found that 77% of the producers
reported a 71% reduction in the use of pesticides. This study
is significant because it covers an area of 37 million ha, which
represents 3% of the area planted in the non-industrialized
countries (Pretty et al., 2006). One of the strategies for managing
agroecological systems is to increase biodiversity, both
planned and associated (Vandermeer, 1995). The increase in
biodiversity is accompanied by the restoration of ecological
processes such as pollination and the predation of herbivores
by natural enemies (Nicholls and Altieri, 1997). Alongside
these benefits, agroecological practices may also increase the
system’s resistance to catastrophes, thereby bolstering its sustainability.
Recently a participatory study by the Movimiento
Campesino a Campesino showed that farms managed with
agroecological practices were more resistant to the impacts
of Hurricane Mitch in Nicaragua (Holt-Giménez, 2001)
(Box 1-5).
1.7.3 Quality and food safety
Food quality and safety is understood as the guarantee that
a food will not cause harm to the consumer, or in other
words that it won’t cause disease. The modern concept incorporates
factors such as agricultural practices, genetic
manipulation, the inclusion of hormones or other drugs in
animals’ diets (Campos, 2000) and post-harvest handling
such as storage conditions and the use of unauthorized additives.
The Codex Alimentarius Commission, established
by the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) and the
World Health Organization (WHO), prepares risk-based
food safety standards that are used as a reference in international
trade and give the countries a model for national
laws (FAO, 2007).
|
|
The concept of food quality has to do with nutritional
value, organoleptic properties such as appearance, color, texture
and flavor and functional properties. Quality is related
to characteristics that determine value or acceptability by
consumers and compliance with standards that ensure that
a product is safe for consumers, not contaminated, adulterated,
or bearing a fraudulent presentation. Safety therefore
has to do with risks associated with production and subsequent
handling, processing and packaging, such as contamination
with agrochemicals (pesticides and fertilizers),
veterinary drugs, or unauthorized food additives; microbiological
risks posed by bacteria, protozoa, parasites, viruses
and fungi or their toxins (mycotoxins, aflatoxins); natural
toxins present in the environment (zinc, arsenic, cyanide) or
in foods themselves (solanine and histamine); and toxic industrial
chemicals or radioactive waste (arsenic, cadmium,
copper, lead, mercury and polychlorinated biphenyls) (FAO,
2000). Exposure to pesticide waste or other contaminants
in the diet has adverse effects on the production and reproduction
of animals and in human populations (Singh et al.,
2007).
Although until a few years ago authorities and researchers
from several countries affirmed that foods produced organically
did not differ significantly in terms of food safety
and nutrition from conventionally grown foods, there is
more and more evidence and official recognition that organic
foods contain lower amounts of residue of additives
and colors, pesticides, veterinary drugs and in many cases
more nitrates and other vitamins, minerals, essential fatty
acids and beneficial antioxidants; and they appear to have
the potential to lower the incidence of cancer, coronary heart
disease, allergies and hyperactivity in children (FAO, 2000;
Cleeton, 2004; Soil Association, 2005, 2007). Baker et al.
(2002) performed a statistical analysis of data on pesticide
residues in 94,000 food samples to describe and quantify
differences between fresh fruits and vegetables from three
different modes of production: conventional, integrated
pest management and organic. A comparison was done of
data from three programs: the Pesticide Data Program of
the US Department of Agriculture; the Marketplace Surveillance
Program of the California Department of Pesticide
Regulation; and tests performed by Consumers Union, an
independent organization. It was found that concentrations
of pesticide residues in organic samples were consistently
lower than in the other two categories and the greatest
concentrations were found in the conventional samples,
which also contain multiple pesticide residues in greater
proportions.
According to Barg and Queirós (2007), in 2004 a study
was carried out in Uruguay on the quality of fruits and
vegetables and levels of contamination by agrochemicals,
with 200 samples. Residues were detected in 72% of them;
in 7% of the cases the maximum residue limits (MRLs)—
established by Codex Alimentarius for individual products—
were exceeded, but in many samples residues of several
different pesticides were detected. Combinations of low
levels of insecticides, herbicides and nitrates have proven to
be toxic at levels at which the chemicals individually considered
are not (Cleeton, 2004). Barg and Queirós (2007)
added that the MRLs allowed are set based on the technolofromCK |